What's the difference? - Moving Coil and Moving Magnet Turntable Cartridges
The difference between MM and MC cartridges can initially be confusing but no need to fear! Read below to learn more about how these cartridges work and what is best suited for you.
What's the difference? - Moving Coil and Moving Magnet Turntable Cartridges
In the realm of vinyl playback, the turntable cartridge is a critical component that translates the grooves of a record into electrical signals, ultimately producing the sound we hear. Two primary types of cartridges dominate the market: moving coil (MC) and moving magnet (MM). While both serve the same fundamental purpose, they employ distinct mechanisms and technologies, each with its own set of advantages and characteristics.
At the heart of the distinction between moving coil and moving magnet cartridges lies the design of their magnetic systems. In a moving magnet cartridge, the stylus is attached to a cantilever that moves within a fixed magnetic field generated by a pair of magnets. As the stylus traces the grooves of the record, it induces changes in the magnetic field, generating electrical signals that are then amplified to produce sound. Conversely, in a moving coil cartridge, the stylus is attached to a lightweight coil of wire that moves within a fixed magnetic field generated by permanent magnets. As the stylus moves, it causes the coil to move relative to the magnets, generating electrical signals that are subsequently amplified.
One of the primary differences between moving coil and moving magnet cartridges lies in their construction and electrical characteristics. Moving magnet cartridges typically feature higher output voltages and impedance levels compared to moving coil cartridges. This higher output voltage makes moving magnet cartridges more compatible with a wider range of phono preamps and amplifiers, simplifying setup and integration into audio systems. Additionally, moving magnet cartridges tend to offer a more forgiving sound signature, with smoother frequency response and less sensitivity to load impedance variations. Some moving coil cartridges by brands such as ‘Hana’ are available with high outputs and can subsequently be used through a moving magnet phono stage.
Moving coil cartridges are prized for their superior transient response, low mass, and high tracking ability. By virtue of their lightweight coil and magnet assembly, moving coil cartridges can respond more quickly to the minute variations in the record groove, capturing finer details and nuances in the music. This results in a more dynamic and engaging listening experience, with improved imaging, resolution, and separation of instruments and vocals. However, due to their lower output voltage and impedance, moving coil cartridges may require a dedicated phono preamp with sufficient gain and load settings to achieve optimal performance.
Another factor to consider when comparing moving coil and moving magnet cartridges is their longevity and maintenance requirements. Moving magnet cartridges typically have replaceable stylus assemblies, making it easy and cost-effective to refresh the cartridge's performance over time. In contrast, moving coil cartridges often have the coil integrated into the cartridge body, necessitating the replacement of the entire cartridge when the stylus wears out. While moving coil cartridges may require less frequent stylus replacement due to their lower mass and reduced wear, the cost of cartridge replacement can be higher compared to moving magnet cartridges.
In conclusion, the choice between moving coil and moving magnet turntable cartridges ultimately boils down to personal preference, system compatibility, and listening priorities. Moving magnet cartridges offer ease of use, versatility, and a forgiving sound signature, making them ideal for beginners and casual listeners. Moving coil cartridges, on the other hand, excel in transient response, detail retrieval, and musicality, appealing to audiophiles and enthusiasts seeking the highest level of performance. Regardless of the choice, both moving coil and moving magnet cartridges play a crucial role in the vinyl playback chain, unlocking the true essence of analogue sound and preserving the magic of vinyl records for generations to come.
Interested in hearing the difference between MM and MC cartridges? Give the store a call on 0131 229 8777 and let us know!
- Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
- Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.